Protecting air-cooled heat exchangers from corrosion and fouling
Air-cooled heat exchangers play a critical role in industrial processes, providing cooling and condensing of hydrocarbon products using ambient air. Ensuring the reliable and safe operation of these air-cooler systems is paramount, as any failure risks the release of hazardous materials into the atmosphere, threatening plant safety and operational continuity.
One of the key challenges faced by air-cooled heat exchangers is corrosion and fouling of the tube surfaces, which can degrade heat transfer performance and lead to catastrophic failures. Recent advancements in protective coating technologies have emerged as a powerful solution to combat these issues, enhancing the lifespan and efficiency of air-cooled heat exchanger systems.
This article delves into the latest developments in air-cooled heat exchanger coatings, exploring how new materials and application techniques are improving corrosion resistance and mitigating fouling concerns. Drawing insights from industry experts and the latest research, we’ll uncover practical tips and in-depth guidance to help plant operators and maintenance teams optimize the performance and reliability of their air-cooled heat exchangers.
The scourge of corrosion and fouling in air-cooled heat exchangers
Air-cooled heat exchangers are susceptible to a range of corrosion and fouling issues that can significantly impact their performance and reliability. Corrosion, whether caused by the cooling water, process fluids, or atmospheric conditions, can lead to pitting, scaling, and even catastrophic tube failures. Simultaneously, the buildup of deposits and scaling on the tube surfaces, known as fouling, reduces heat transfer efficiency and increases pressure drop, ultimately impairing the exchanger’s thermal performance.
Cooling water pitting and deposit corrosion have long plagued manufacturers, leading many to specify more corrosion-resistant alloy materials, such as stainless steel, titanium, or copper alloys, for their air-cooler tube bundles. However, even with these upgraded alloy materials, tube-side fouling and scaling can still remain a persistent issue, hindering overall system efficiency and reliability.
Combating corrosion and fouling with protective coatings
To address these challenges, a new generation of durable, low-surface energy coatings has emerged, demonstrating significant improvements in combating corrosion and fouling in air-cooled heat exchangers. These advanced coatings leverage the latest material science research to create thin-film barriers that not only protect against corrosion but also inhibit the buildup of deposits and scaling on the tube surfaces.
By applying these coatings to air-cooler tube bundles, manufacturers and operators can realize several key benefits:
-
Enhanced corrosion resistance: The coatings form a protective barrier that shields the underlying alloy material from corrosive attack, extending the service life of the heat exchanger.
-
Improved anti-fouling performance: The low-surface energy characteristics of the coatings discourage the adhesion of deposits and scaling, reducing the impact of fouling on heat transfer efficiency.
-
Easier cleaning and maintenance: The smooth, non-stick surface of the coatings makes it easier to clean and restore the exchanger’s performance, reducing the frequency and cost of maintenance interventions.
-
Reduced operational costs: By mitigating corrosion and fouling, these protective coatings can help minimize unplanned downtime, improve energy efficiency, and extend the overall lifespan of the air-cooled heat exchanger.
Durable, low-surface energy coatings for air-cooled heat exchangers
The latest advancements in material research have led to the development of a new generation of durable, low-surface energy coatings that are proving highly effective in addressing the corrosion and fouling challenges faced by air-cooled heat exchangers.
These thin-film coatings, typically less than 50 microns in thickness, leverage a range of innovative materials and application techniques to deliver superior performance:
Reduced surface tension and increased hydrophobicity
The coatings are formulated to have a very low surface tension, often less than 25 dynes/cm2, which is significantly lower than that of newly fabricated stainless steel tubes. This reduced surface tension, combined with a marginally smoother surface roughness, creates a high contact angle (greater than 90 degrees) between the tube surface and fluids, inhibiting “wetting” and promoting a hydrophobic or oleophobic behavior.
Enhanced release properties
The combination of low surface tension and high contact angle results in a “non-stick” surface that discourages the adhesion of deposits and scaling. This “foul release” characteristic helps to minimize the buildup of fouling on the tube surfaces, preserving heat transfer efficiency and reducing the frequency of cleaning interventions.
Durable and long-lasting
The coatings are formulated to be highly durable, withstanding the harsh operating conditions and thermal cycling experienced by air-cooled heat exchangers. They exhibit excellent adhesion to a variety of alloy materials, including stainless steel, titanium, and copper alloys, ensuring long-lasting protection against corrosion and fouling.
Flexible application techniques
These protective coatings can be applied to new exchanger tube bundles during the manufacturing process or used to refurbish and restore existing air-cooled heat exchangers that have experienced corrosion and fouling. The thin-film nature of the coatings ensures a minimal impact on the exchanger’s designed performance, making them a versatile solution for a wide range of applications.
Case studies: Proven performance in air-cooled heat exchangers
The benefits of these advanced protective coatings have been demonstrated in numerous real-world applications, where they have helped to extend the lifespan and improve the reliability of air-cooled heat exchangers across various industries.
Extending the service life of stainless steel exchangers
In one case, a Gulf Coast refinery had a 304 stainless steel exchanger that had been in service for over 14 years, with the tube-IDs and tubesheets coated during the original fabrication. When the exchanger was pulled for replacement, it passed a hydrostatic test, and previous inspections had shown no signs of tube degradation. This allowed the refinery to develop a restoration plan that included Curran’s cleaning, non-destructive testing, and recoating of the exchanger, ensuring its continued reliable operation.
Protecting carbon steel exchangers from corrosion
As water treatment practices evolved and carbon steel became a more cost-effective material for fabrication, Curran’s exchanger tube-ID coatings became a valuable add-on for in-kind replacement of carbon steel exchangers. Several Gulf Coast refineries made Curran’s tube-ID coating a standard requirement for their carbon steel exchanger bundle replacements, providing a reliable barrier against corrosion and fouling.
Demonstrating the value of coatings through comparative analysis
In one comparative study, a Texas Gulf Coast refinery had two identical floating head exchangers, with only one of the two being coated during the original fabrication. After several years of operation on the same cooling water circuit, the exchangers were pulled and sent to Curran for cleaning and inspection. The uncoated exchanger showed clear signs of generalized surface corrosion down the tube-ID, while the coated exchanger exhibited no such degradation, highlighting the protective benefits of the applied coating.
These case studies showcase the real-world performance and value of durable, low-surface energy coatings in extending the service life, reducing maintenance costs, and improving the reliability of air-cooled heat exchangers across various industrial settings.
Curran International’s expertise in air-cooled heat exchanger coatings
As a leading provider of protective coatings for industrial heat exchangers, Curran International has been at the forefront of developing and applying durable, low-surface energy coatings to air-cooled heat exchanger tube bundles for decades.
Curran’s coatings are formulated using a range of innovative materials, including sol-gel, preceramic polymers, and epoxy-silicone blends, to deliver exceptional corrosion resistance and anti-fouling performance. These coatings have been extensively tested and proven in the field, withstanding temperatures up to 365°F (185°C) and providing a reliable barrier against a variety of corrosive environments.
In addition to the application of these protective coatings, Curran International has also pioneered a unique, self-contained tube-cleaning method for air-cooled exchangers. This dry-grit blasting technique efficiently scours the tube-IDs to “near-white metal” cleanliness, preparing the surfaces for high-integrity non-destructive testing (NDT) inspections without the need for cumbersome containment or cleanup.
Curran’s expertise in air-cooled heat exchanger coatings and cleaning methods has been honed over decades of experience, helping plant operators and maintenance teams across a wide range of industries to optimize the performance, reliability, and lifespan of their critical air-cooler systems.
Conclusion: Unlocking the potential of air-cooled heat exchangers
The advancements in durable, low-surface energy coatings have unlocked new possibilities for enhancing the performance and reliability of air-cooled heat exchangers. By providing robust protection against corrosion and fouling, these innovative coatings are helping plant operators and maintenance teams to:
- Extend the service life of air-cooler tube bundles, reducing the frequency of costly replacements
- Improve heat transfer efficiency by minimizing the impact of deposit buildup and scaling
- Streamline maintenance and cleaning interventions, lowering operational costs
- Ensure the safe and reliable operation of critical air-cooled heat exchanger systems
As the industry continues to evolve, the ongoing development of advanced coating technologies, coupled with Curran International’s expertise in application and cleaning methods, will play a crucial role in unlocking the full potential of air-cooled heat exchangers across a wide range of industrial settings.
To learn more about Curran International’s air-cooled heat exchanger coatings and services, please visit https://www.aircooledheatexchangers.net/ or call 281.339.9993.
